(74904dc) Let a ticket field be cleared back to unset, and bump to 0.18.0

`set --clear <field>` is the one way to take a value away, repeatable, with
the field as a `ValueEnum` value: an unknown one is a usage error listing the
six that are not, and the shells complete them for free. Not a per-field
`--clear-due`, which is a flag per field to keep in step with the one it
undoes, and not an empty value, which is already a paragraph break for a
section and would make an accidentally empty variable a silent delete.

What goes back is what `add` writes for a field it was never given, through
the new `NOT_SET` and `NONE` constants and each section's placeholder, so a
cleared ticket and one filed without the field read the same. Sections are in
scope and go back through `clear_section_body` rather than
`set_section_body`: the latter runs its items through `Section::render`, which
would have written `- [ ] _No acceptance criteria provided._`.

Owner is `chown --clear <ticket>`, so the field keeps its one writer. The flag
carries the ticket because the ticket is chown's second positional and a bare
flag would land it in the user's slot for the handler to read back out, which
is hand-parsing what clap can state. It writes `_Not set_` rather than the git
user: `add` falls back to the git user because it is filing something new, and
an owner taken away says nobody owns this.

The empty-value error split in two rather than being reworded. `non_empty`
says only that the value cannot be empty, for the arguments with no empty
form; `clearable` names `--clear`, for the arguments whose field has one. One
message for both would have lied about `ls --tag`.

Replacing and clearing one field in a single call is refused rather than
resolved by whichever was applied last, and cleared fields are reported as
`Cleared due on '...'` beside `Updated priority on '...'`, since one list
would say `Updated` of a field that was emptied.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Ansho Rei
2026-08-23 00:04:28 +02:00
co-authored by Claude Opus 5
parent 175c1d016d
commit cc5f9b8a46
15 changed files with 810 additions and 92 deletions
+15 -11
View File
@@ -16,11 +16,12 @@ which command owns which field. Read it too. This document is the judgement.
**Propose the whole set of edits, wait, then apply exactly what was approved.**
Every job here writes to many tickets at once, and no field can be cleared back to unset
yet, so a date written onto the wrong ticket can only be overwritten, never taken off. A wrong
edit to one ticket is a mistake; a wrong sweep is thirty of them with no undo. So a
proposal is a list, one line per intended edit, each naming the ticket and the command
that would make it:
Every job here writes to many tickets at once, and nothing on the board records what a
field held before you wrote to it. `--clear` puts a field back to unset, which is **not
back to what it held**, so a date written over another date is gone. A wrong edit to one
ticket is a mistake; a wrong sweep is thirty of them with no undo. So a proposal is a
list, one line per intended edit, each naming the ticket and the command that would make
it:
```
(1b78a24) priority 3 -> 1 worklane set 1b78a24 --priority 1
@@ -37,10 +38,10 @@ other way is editing the file by hand:
| Field | Writer |
|-------|--------|
| Priority, Due, Tags | `worklane set <ticket> --priority` / `--due` / `--tags` |
| Priority, Due, Tags | `worklane set <ticket> --priority` / `--due` / `--tags`, and `--clear <field>` to empty one |
| Relations | `worklane relate <ticket> --blocked-by` / `--regression-of` / `--relates-to` |
| Campaign membership | `worklane assign <campaign> <ticket>` |
| Owner | `worklane chown <user> <ticket>` |
| Owner | `worklane chown <user> <ticket>`, and `worklane chown --clear <ticket>` to empty it |
| Status | `worklane mv <ticket> --status <target>` |
**Never edit a ticket file directly.** The filename, the `Status` field and the directory
@@ -101,8 +102,9 @@ What to look for:
A value that is not a real calendar date in that exact form is refused before anything
is written, so a typo costs nothing. `2026-8-9` is refused too: the padding is part of
the format. What is still true is that a date, once written, **cannot be cleared**, only
replaced by another date, so a plan applied to the wrong ticket has no undo.
the format. A date can be taken off again with `worklane set <ticket> --clear due`. What
that cannot do is recover the date that was there before it, so a plan applied over
existing dates still has no undo.
Ask the system what today is rather than assuming it. A plan built on a guessed date is
wrong by however much the guess was wrong.
@@ -119,13 +121,15 @@ The rules a dating plan has to keep:
whole backlog produces a board where every ticket is late, which is the same as no
dates at all.
- **Do not date `done`.** It is finished; a date on it is noise in every listing.
- Leave the rest unset. An unset due date is honest about what has not been planned.
- Leave the rest unset. An unset due date is honest about what has not been planned, and
a date that turned out to be wrong is better cleared than left to read as a plan.
## Tags
`worklane set <ticket> --tags bug,cli` is the writer, and it **replaces the whole
field**. Restate every tag the ticket should keep, or the ones you left out are gone.
This is the single most destructive thing in this document.
This is the single most destructive thing in this document. `--clear tags` empties the
field on purpose, which is a different thing from emptying it by forgetting a tag.
Derive the vocabulary from the board rather than inventing one. Read the tickets, count
what is actually used, and show the count before proposing anything. What to report:
+21 -7
View File
@@ -124,21 +124,34 @@ worklane add \
Editing afterwards, on a ticket in any status:
```
worklane set 1b78a24 --priority 1 # replace a field
worklane set 1b78a24 --priority 1 # replace a field
worklane set 1b78a24 --title "A better title" # renames the file, keeps the uuid
worklane set 1b78a24 --clear due # take a value away again
worklane set 1b78a24 --clear tags --clear plan # as many fields as you like
worklane append 1b78a24 --acceptance "One more criterion"
worklane append 1b78a24 --description "What was learned since."
worklane chown alice 1b78a24 # hand the ticket to someone
worklane chown --clear 1b78a24 # hand it back to nobody
```
`set` replaces, `append` adds. Neither has `--owner` or `--status`: owner is `chown`'s
and status is `mv`'s, so each field has exactly one writer. A field set to the value it
already holds is reported unchanged and nothing is written.
`set` replaces, `append` adds, `--clear` empties. Neither `set` nor `append` has
`--owner` or `--status`: owner is `chown`'s and status is `mv`'s, so each field has
exactly one writer. A field set to the value it already holds is reported unchanged and
nothing is written, and so is a field cleared that was already unset.
**`--clear` takes the field as its value**, one of `due`, `tags`, `priority`,
`description`, `acceptance` or `plan`, and repeats. It writes back exactly what `add`
writes for a field it was never given: `_Not set_`, `_None_` for tags, and the section
placeholder. There is no `--clear title`, because a title addresses the ticket and names
its file. There is no `--clear owner` either: that is `chown --clear <ticket>`, which
takes the ticket in the flag since there is no user to give, and returns the field to
unset rather than to the git user. Replacing and clearing the same field in one call is
refused rather than resolved.
`chown` takes the **user first and the ticket second**, after Unix `chown`, which is the
one command here that does not start with the ticket. The user is free text and is
checked against nothing. Swap the two and the call fails, because the username has to
resolve as a ticket.
resolve as a ticket. `--clear` replaces both arguments with the ticket alone.
`worklane init` creates `.worklane/` with the four status directories and the campaigns
directory beside them, for a repo that has no board yet.
@@ -261,6 +274,7 @@ the candidates and exits 1 rather than guessing.
`worklane mv --status committed -- -leading-title`.
- A comment body of exactly `--` needs its own separator:
`worklane comment 1b78a24 -- --`.
- An empty value for a scalar is a usage error. Clearing a field back to unset is not
supported yet.
- An empty value for a scalar is a usage error, not a way to clear the field: use
`--clear`. For a section an empty value is a paragraph break, so it cannot mean empty
the section either, and an all-blank one is refused with the `--clear` for it named.
- Piping is safe: `worklane ls | head -3` exits on the closed pipe instead of panicking.