(bc86c85) Attribute a command typed at the board to the person, not the variable, and bump to 0.33.5
WORKLANE_ACTOR is set once in the environment an agent runs in, which is
right for an agent and wrong for the board: a person who exports it where
their own shell picks it up, the obvious way to configure it for the agents
on that machine, then moved a ticket with ':' and the board recorded the
move as the agent's.
Nothing but the reader can type that line, so the prompt asks for
--actor-from-git's precedence without the flag. An explicit --actor still
wins, which is how the reader puts somebody else's name on their own
keystrokes, and a machine with no git user configured reads unknown rather
than falling back to the variable, for the reason the flag does.
The attribution is a parameter of dispatch rather than a field the prompt
writes into what clap parsed: rewriting the arguments would need an arm per
entry-writing command, and the command added after it would be attributed
to the agent until somebody noticed. no_handler_decides_its_own_attribution
reads src for a handler naming an Attribution of its own, which the
compiler cannot catch because it compiles.
The same command typed in a shell is unchanged, which is what keeps a board
several agents write to saying which of them wrote what.
Also closes a code fence in the skill that e26e589 left open, duplicating
the mv --actor example under it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
co-authored by
Claude Opus 5
parent
a885f81da5
commit
3e732535f8
@@ -5,6 +5,8 @@ Who an entry is attributed to, and what the log does and does not record.
|
||||
## Who Wrote an Entry
|
||||
- **Identity is supplied, not detected.** Every option that needs no cooperation fails: a harness variable such as `CLAUDECODE` names the tool rather than the instance and breaks across versions, walking the parent process is platform specific and also only names the harness, and a terminal check separates interactive from not, which a human piping output is too. So the actor is `WORKLANE_ACTOR`, set once per session, with `--actor` as the per-call override
|
||||
- **Precedence: flag, then `WORKLANE_ACTOR`, then `get_git_user()`, then `unknown`.** With `--actor-from-git` and no explicit value the git user is lifted *above* the variable rather than added beneath it — the flag says attribute this to the human, and a machine with no git user configured reads `unknown` instead of quietly attributing back to the agent. An explicit `--actor` wins outright either way. `resolve_actor` is the only caller of `get_git_user` for an entry's author, and every entry the CLI writes goes through it. The halves are separate pure functions, `session_actor` (the variable alone now) and `entry_actor`, tested without touching the process environment for the reason `colors_wanted` is split that way
|
||||
- **A command typed at the board is the person's, not the session's.** `dispatch` takes an `Attribution`, `Session` from `main` and `Person` from the command prompt, and `Person` asks for `--actor-from-git`'s lift without the flag: nothing but the reader can type that line, and a person who exported `WORKLANE_ACTOR` where their own shell picks it up — the obvious way to configure it for the agents on that machine — would otherwise watch their own `mv` recorded as the agent's. An explicit `--actor` still wins there, which is how the reader puts somebody else's name on their own keystrokes, and with no git user configured the entry reads `unknown` rather than falling back to the variable, for the reason the flag does. `entry_actor` takes it beside `from_git` and the two are one branch, since `--actor-from-git` typed at the prompt asks for what the prompt does anyway
|
||||
- **The attribution is a parameter of `dispatch`, not a field the prompt writes into the parsed arguments.** Rewriting what clap produced would need an arm per entry-writing command, and the command added after it would be attributed to the agent until somebody noticed. A parameter is one edit for both callers, and `no_handler_decides_its_own_attribution` reads `src` for a handler naming an `Attribution` of its own, which the compiler cannot catch because it compiles
|
||||
- **The variable half is cached in a `OnceLock` and the git user in another**, the way `should_use_colors` is: neither input can change mid-run, and the git user costs a subprocess. Two caches rather than one is the whole point: baking the git user into the session's answer would make `--actor-from-git` read whatever the run's *first* call produced, since with the variable set that call never fetched git at all. `entry_actor` takes the git user as a closure so the subprocess is not run when something ahead of it already answered
|
||||
- **The two flags are refused together at parse time**, clap `conflicts_with`: both answer who the entry is attributed to, and last-wins would be a silent answer to a contradictory call. `every_actor_command_takes_actor_from_git` walks the clap definition so the pair travels together onto any command that grows an `--actor`
|
||||
- An **empty `WORKLANE_ACTOR` counts as unset**, the convention `colors_wanted` follows for `NO_COLOR`, so a wrapper script can clear an inherited one. Whitespace counts the same, since a shell quoting a missing value writes one
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -24,6 +24,7 @@ The three input modes on the board and the key that copies an id off it.
|
||||
- **`refused` is cleared by an edit and not by a movement.** The message is about the line, and moving the cursor does not change the line. `Prompt::key` clears it in the three arms that write to the line
|
||||
- **A line that ends inside a quote never reaches clap.** That is what `Unclosed` is for: a grammar complaint about a sentence nobody finished describes the wrong thing. Enter on an empty line, or one of nothing but separators, closes the prompt with nothing said, the way `esc` does — the bare form of the CLI opens a board and there is one on the screen
|
||||
- **Enter runs it, through `main.rs`'s `dispatch` and never through a handler this file names.** That match is the one mapping from a parsed command to the function that performs it: `main` calls it with its own stdout and the working directory, `Board::run` calls it with a buffer and the selected tab's root. A second copy inside `tui.rs` would drift the first time a command was added, and it would drift *silently*, since both halves go on compiling. The match is exhaustive so a new verb cannot fall into an `_` arm and do nothing, and `main_and_the_prompt_run_one_dispatch_table` reads both files as text to pin it. Only `tui` is matched outside the table, in `main`, because the board is that table's caller rather than an entry in it; reached from the prompt it is refused in those words
|
||||
- **What it writes is attributed to the person at the board**, through the same `dispatch` parameter, because a line nothing but the reader can type is the reader's action. The rule and its precedence are in [history.md](history.md), which owns attribution; what belongs here is that the board is the one caller that asks for it
|
||||
- **`from_arg_matches` on the same matches gives `run` the typed values.** One parse, two readings: `command_name` walks the subcommands to name what resolved and `from_arg_matches` reconstructs the `Cli`. A `match` over every `Command` variant to get one or the other would be a second list of every verb the CLI has
|
||||
- **The handler's own words are what the board reports, word for word.** Those messages are written for a person already, and a second set kept here would go stale the first time one of them changed. The sink is a buffer, so the words come back as text and the board styles them; it is plain for the same reason `Detail` holds spans, since a ratatui paragraph prints an escape rather than obeying it. An error never goes through a sink at all — `color_text` asks the *process* about its stdout, which under the board answers yes about a terminal the message is not going to — so `error_lines` runs `without_escapes` over it and puts each cause on a line of its own
|
||||
- **A warning goes through the sink's second stream, and never through `eprintln!`.** `Sink` carries two writers because the CLI's two streams are two: `Sink::std` hands the answer to stdout and an aside to stderr, and a shell has to go on reading the same line on the same stream. Under the board neither is a stream at all — stderr is the alternate screen with the columns on it — so `Sink::buffer` *holds* its warnings and `Board::run` reads them back with `Sink::warnings` and puts them above the answer, on both outcomes: a `mv` that warns about a dangling blocker and is then refused by a real one wrote the aside first, and it is the half that says why the refusal names one blocker and the ticket records two. That is c680e24: one `eprintln!` in `check_blockers` outlived fa5662a because a helper had no sink to reach, and ratatui does not repaint a cell it believes is unchanged, so the fragment stayed on the columns until something else redrew them. `no_handler_or_helper_reaches_a_print_macro` walks `src` for the next one, each file cut at its test module, so a print site in a module added tomorrow is caught the day it is added
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user